COMPLETEDNA
Individual MBCT vs. CBT in Major Depression: A Pilot Study.
NCT05108701
Background: Depression is a highly recurrent disorder, which often requires lifelong treatment. Psychotherapy has an important role in the treatment of depression, both in the treatment of the acute phase and in prevention of relapses. Mindfulness-based therapies have become popular in the last decade. Mindfulness-based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) is an established treatment for relapse prevention in Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) and there is preliminary evidence of its efficacy in treating acute symptoms. Several studies have highlighted the benefits of MBCT in reducing the severity of depressive symptoms in patients diagnosed with a current Major Depressive Episode, as indicated by some meta-analyses showing that MBCT is more effective than treatment as usual in decreasing depressive symptoms and equivalent to active treatments. However, the results at follow-up were less conclusive, due to the limited number of studies and moderate-to-large heterogeneity within the subgroups.
A number of studies have examined the effects of MBCT on a larger spectrum of factors that can affect the severity of depression. In patients with MDD, MBCT was more effective than treatment as usual in decreasing rumination, worry, negative affect and dysfunctional attitudes, increasing mindfulness skills and positive affect and improving sleep and quality of life. However, data comparing the specific effect of MBCT with other active treatments (for example Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, CBT) are lacking.
Most trials exploring the efficacy of MBCT have been conducted with group MBCT, but there is less evidence about the use of individual MBCT (I-MBCT). Individual MBCT may have some advantages, compared with group therapy, such as better attendance and higher efficacy in major depression, when compared with group therapy. Furthermore, the individual format can often be better tailored to a specific patient, with a slower progression and a longer number of sessions, if needed.
Objective: The primary objective of this pilot trial was to test the feasibility of a larger randomized trial examining the changes in depressive and anxiety symptoms, rumination, mindfulness, emotion regulation, behavioral activation and negative automatic thoughts during I-MBCT and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). Further objectives were: (a) replicating studies evaluating the efficacy of I-MBCT to improve depression, in particularly in patients diagnosed with a major depressive disorder; (b) assessing the persistence of benefits of I-MBCT after the end of treatment; (c) comparing the effects of I-MBCT with CBT, not only on depressive symptoms, but also on factors which are specifically targeted by MBCT, such as rumination and mindfulness; explore possible predictors of outcome of MBCT.
Hypotheses: We make the following hypotheses: a) a larger trial comparing I-MBCT with CBT examining the changes of depressive and anxiety symptoms, rumination, mindfulness, emotion regulation, behavioral activation and negative automatic thoughts is feasible, with recruitment rates and drop-off rates consistent with those usually observed among participants with current major depression; b) the levels of depressive and anxiety symptoms, rumination, emotion dysregulation, and negative automatic thoughts will decrease during I-MBCT, while the levels of mindfulness and behavioral activation will increase, with effect sizes similar to those observed in CBT; c) the changes in depressive and anxiety symptoms, rumination, emotion dysregulation, negative automatic thoughts, mindfulness and behavioral activation will be maintained at follow-up; d) the changes in mindfulness and rumination dimensions are expected to be larger during MBCT than CBT; these analyses will be exploratory, given the state of knowledge; d) we will explore the role of predictors of clinical variables, such as earlier age at onset of the mood disorder; longer and more severe current episode; presence of current comorbidity with anxiety disorders, initial levels of anxiety, behavioral activation, emotion dysregulation and of the history of severe childhood maltreatment in predicting the outcome to MBCT and CBT.
Major Depressive Disorder
The Royal Ottawa Mental Health Centre27 participantsStarted Nov 2015 