Precision Brain Stimulation to Reduce Cannabis Craving in Schizophrenia

Cannabis use is highly prevalent in schizophrenia and has devastating consequences but no current treatments. Psychotic disorders such as schizophrenia are disabling, lifelong illnesses that afflict over three million people in the US. Cannabis is the second-most commonly used substance by people with schizophrenia (SZ) after tobacco. Up to 43% of people with SZ meet criteria for cannabis use disorder (CUD), a rate 15 times that in the general population of 3%. Recent evidence suggests cannabis use and SZ have bidirectional causal relationships. Co-occurring SZ with CUD has a significantly worse prognosis than SZ alone, as CUD is associated with symptom exacerbation, risk of psychotic relapse, treatment nonadherence, and poorer overall functioning. Cannabis use is a frequent cause of medication nonadherence, psychotic decompensation, and psychiatric hospitalization. Cannabis use in adolescence commonly occurs prior to the onset of psychosis, and there is growing evidence that cannabis may cause schizophrenia in vulnerable individuals. Recent evidence shows that cannabis use triggers brain changes linked to psychosis. However, the underlying pathophysiology of SZ with CUD remains unknown, and there are no approved treatments for SZ with CUD, leaving patients and their families struggling to stop their cannabis use without any effective treatments. Cannabis Use in Schizophrenia is Based in Brain Network Pathology. Despite the magnitude of cannabis use and its devastating consequences, there are no approved treatments for cannabis use in any population. This study team seeks to investigate if this vulnerability to cannabis use in schizophrenia is based in brain pathology. The human brain is organized into networks of connected regions. In cannabis users, a region of these networks is chronically hyperconnected, but cannabis use transiently corrects this network pathology. This suggests cannabis users are using cannabis to self-medicate a network pathology problem. Function of brain networks can be measured in the MRI scanner. This study seeks to use functional connectivity as a measure of neural function. The human brain has evolved to perform different behaviors under different sets of conditions and as such must flexibly combine the functional processing capabilities of disparate neuroanatomical regions. Collections of structurally interconnected brain areas must interact dynamically to process a large and ever-changing set of inputs in the ultimate attempt to generate an appropriate behavioral output. Functional networks can therefore be defined as the collection of interconnected brain areas that interact to perform these circumscribed functions. To identify the critical nodes involved in these different functional networks, much of the work in the field of functional neuroimaging has used the fMRI blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) signal as a marker of cerebral perfusion, which in turn is known to reflect cerebral activity. fMRI BOLD activation patterns have revealed network nodes that are involved in such cognitive functions as attention working memory, language, and others. In the resting state--while a participant is asked simply to look straight without performing a specific task in the MRI--analyses of the time-course of BOLD activation have revealed that activity patterns of several of these cerebral nodes exhibit coordinated fluctuations. As such, the activity patterns between particular nodes appear to be highly correlated in time while others seem relatively independent of one another. Taken together, these coordinated nodes can be thought of as a coupled functional network. The correlations between the activity patterns of cerebral nodes are termed "functional connectivity." DMN Hyperconnectivity is associated with cannabis use and is improved by cannabis administration. In healthy cannabis users, parietal default mode network (DMN) hyperconnectivity has been observed during rest and task conditions. Moreover, the parietal DMN activates to cannabis cues, and cannabis administration reduces parietal DMN connectivity. The relationship will also be observed in psychosis: in a large sample of individuals with psychosis (Prelim Data #1, n= 596), higher DMN connectivity was related to more lifetime cannabis use. Higher DMN connectivity was also associated with higher craving in SZ (Prelim Data #2, r=0.49, p=.0097). DMN hyperconnectivity is a well-established observation in SZ. Critically, the only study of cannabis administration among SZ with CUD showed that both cannabis and THC normalized DMN hyperconnectivity to the level of healthy controls (Whitfield-Gabrieli et al. 2018). These convergent data suggest that parietal DMN hyperconnectivity in SZ may be further exacerbated by cannabis use, suggesting the parietal DMN may be a prime target for intervention. 5\) rTMS is an FDA-Approved Treatment for Substance Use that Can Selectively Target Brain Network Pathology TMS, (Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation) is a non-invasive, easily transportable, and relatively inexpensive procedure that utilizes magnetic fields to create electric currents in discrete brain regions. TMS is based on Faraday's principle of electromagnetic induction and features application of rapidly changing magnetic field pulses to the scalp via a copper wire coil connected to a magnetic stimulator. These brief pulsed magnetic fields painlessly pass through the skull and create electric currents in discrete brain regions of sufficient magnitude to depolarize neurons. Applied in single pulses (single-pulse TMS) appropriately delivered in time and space, the currents induced in the brain can be of sufficient magnitude to depolarize a population of neurons. When applied to the motor cortex, this depolarization results in a series of descending (direct and indirect) corticospinal waves that can sum-up at the spinal segmental level, depolarize alpha motor neurons and lead to the contraction of contralateral muscles. This can be measured, for example, as motor evoked potentials (MEPs) using electromyography (EMG). Applied to any cortical region, TMS evokes a local field potential that can be recorded with EEG, or other brain imaging techniques, and reveals a measure of cortical reactivity to TMS. TMS intensity can be parametrically varied in its intensity thus allowing the establishment of a dose-response curve and providing insights into cortical excitability. Trains of repeated TMS pulses (rTMS) at various stimulation frequencies and patterns can induce a lasting modification of activity in the targeted brain region which can outlast the effects of the stimulation itself. Such lasting changes presumably represent alterations in plasticity mechanisms. Therefore, rTMS can be used with repeated pulses to facilitate activity in a region of the brain or suppress activity in a region of the brain. When international safety guidelines are followed, rTMS is a safe and well-tolerated intervention for people with and without psychiatric illness. rTMS is currently an FDA-approved treatment for major depressive disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and smoking cessation. FDA-approved treatment for major depressive disorder generally involves 20-30 daily sessions of rTMS delivered to the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (L DLPFC). However, the FDA recently cleared the SAINT protocol for depression, which involves a total of 50 sessions over 5 days (10 sessions/day). FDA-approved treatment for smoking cessation involves treatment to the L and R DLPFC and has been shown to significantly reduce cigarette consumption and craving in smokers without psychiatric illness. rTMS is a Safe and Effective Treatment for People with Schizophrenia. rTMS has been studied in thousands of people with schizophrenia for a number of different indications, for example auditory verbal hallucinations (systematic review of n = 960 participants), negative symptoms (systematic review, n = 2633 participants), cognitive deficits (systematic review, n = 351 participants) and nicotine dependence. In a meta-analysis of the safety of rTMS in schizophrenia conducted by the PI, it was found that the prevalence of side effects from rTMS for individuals with schizophrenia was at or below the prevalence in the general population. People with schizophrenia were NOT at higher risk for worsening of psychiatric symptoms or seizure. Notably, rTMS is approved for suppression of treatment-refractory auditory hallucinations in schizophrenia by the National Institutes of Mental Health (NIMH). Additionally, a systematic review of 524 individuals with schizophrenia who received intermittent theta burst stimulation (i.e. excitatory theta burst TMS), they noted, "Overall iTBS was well tolerated in patients with schizophrenia". There were no significant differences observed in adverse events between active and sham iTBS, and no seizures were reported. The Safety of TMS Consensus Group recommended, "available data indicate no additional risks of major AEs \[adverse events\] in specific patient populations \[including schizophrenia\] so this is not a concern that needs to be taken into account, at least with the protocols of intervention considered" . No seizures were observed in any of these systematic reviews. rTMS is a Safe and Effective Treatment for Substance Use Disorders, Including Cannabis User. TMS is FDA-approved for treatment of nicotine use disorder and has been tested in thousands of individuals with substance use disorders (Mehta et al. 2023). rTMS for cannabis use disorder has been studied in multiple studies in both the general population and in schizophrenia without any safety concerns. In schizophrenia, 20 sessions of rTMS applied to the DLPFC led to reductions in cannabis use and improvement in cognitive performance. Past studies by this research group have conducted rTMS studies showing that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS reduces DMN connectivity. In Prelim Data #3, individuals with SZ received single sessions of Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS (active and sham) with MRI immediately before and after rTMS. Past studies have observed that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS reduced DMN connectivity compared to sham rTMS (p=.0028, Figure 2). Previously, this research team has also conducted rTMS studies showing that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS in SZ reduces craving, while Conventional DLPFC-targeted iTBS does not (Prelim Data #4). As pilot data for the proposed study, individuals with SZ underwent 5 daily sessions of 1) Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS and 2) Conventional DLFPC-targeted iTBS in a crossover design with MRI and craving assessment before and after each rTMS week. It was observed that only Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS significantly reduced craving in SZ (n=7, p\<.05). It has also been shown in preliminary analyses that 5 sessions of Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS improves processing speed in people with schizophrenia and substance use (t(9)=3.311, p=.009). This provides 1) reassuring evidence that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS will not worsen cognitive performance; and 2) further support for our scientific hypotheses that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS may improve cognitive performance. These data show that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS corrects abnormal DMN connectivity and reduces craving in SZ, supporting our hypothesis that Default Mode Network-targeted cTBS will normalize DMN connectivity and reduce cannabis craving. Brief rTMS Treatments Can Safely Test the Effectiveness of Longer Treatment in the Future. In addition to its effectiveness as a treatment, rTMS is also a versatile research tool whose stimulation parameters can be changed. Depending on the parameters, rTMS can be excitatory or inhibitory. Intermittent theta burst stimulation (iTBS) and continuous theta burst stimulation (cTBS) are types of rTMS. iTBS is associated with excitatory effects which increase connectivity, while cTBS is associated with inhibitory effects which decrease connectivity. rTMS is FDA-approved for smoking cessation and can change brain network connectivity and craving in many substance use disorders. Existing studies of rTMS for cannabis use in control and schizophrenia samples have targeted the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) with modest effects on craving and use. These mixed findings suggest that perhaps DLPFC is not the ideal rTMS target for schizophrenia and that the parietal DMN might be more effective. In this study, 2 rTMS interventions will be compared in a crossover design: 1) 5 sessions of rTMS delivered to the Default Mode Network (as previously have performed in schizophrenia) and 2) 5 sessions of rTMS delivered to the L DLPFC (as in FDA-approved treatment for major depressive disorder). The researchers will test if a 5-session rTMS intervention can cause short-term changes in 1) resting-state network functional connectivity, 2) cue-induced craving, and 3) cognitive performance in both healthy individuals who use cannabis and people with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder who use cannabis. The researchers here test a model that integrates brain network pathophysiology and cognition to 1) explain the extremely high prevalence of cannabis use in schizophrenia and 2) identify a treatment target for future clinical trials in schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder. Previous studies by our group and others have demonstrated the ability of rTMS to change patterns of activity in cortical networks of the human brain. In addition, the research team has also previously demonstrated the ability to both increase and decrease connectivity within a specific network (e.g. DMN) by neuroanatomically targeted rTMS. In the present study, one rTMS intervention will be delivered to the parietal node of the DMN, a region linked to cannabis use in schizophrenia in a network key to attentional and working memory performance, and one rTMS intervention will be delivered to the L DLPFC, a region responsible for executive function, an aspect of cognition key to reducing substance use. Participants will receive pre-post nueroimaging, as well as a baseline MRI scan during the screening visit. When previously applied a single session of rTMS to a parietal node of the DMN in individuals with schizophrenia, a significant effect on craving was observed.