The brain is a major target for circulating gonadal steroids and the change in hormone levels after menopause is likely to have implications for cognitive functioning. Clinical and preclinical studies have linked gonadal steroids and cognition and it has been hypothesized that menopause has detrimental effects on cognition that are over and above the expected effects of normal aging. However, evidence for changes in cognition after menopause is equivocal. Some studies found decreased cognitive performance after menopause in domains such as memory, attention, problem solving, and motor skills. Other studies have not found changes in cognition after menopause. Additionally, not all women experience negative effects of menopause on cognition. The neurobiological processes underlying individual differences in cognition after menopause are not fully understood.
Choline is an essential nutrient that, in addition to its role in the brain, has a number of critical structural and physiologic roles throughout the body, including providing structural integrity and signaling function for cell membranes, facilitating lipid transport from the liver, and acting as the major source of methyl groups through diet. Aside from dietary intake, the only source of choline in the body is de novo synthesis of phosphatidylcholine, catalyzed by phosphatdylethanolamine-N-methyltransferase (PEMT). The PEMT gene has several estrogen-responsive components in its promoter region and is induced by estrogen. Post-menopausal (hypo-estrogenic) women with loss of function mutations in PEMT have been found to exhibit end-organ damage typical of choline deficiency.
Choline is also involved in the synthesis of acetylcholine, a major neurotransmitter and the central and peripheral nervous systems. The relationship between brain effects of the normal functioning of the cholinergic system and hormone changes after menopause has been demonstrated in preclinical studies in rat models and in experimentally in human studies. While the preclinical and clinical experiment studies have many similar findings regarding the influence of estrogen on cholinergic functioning, what is not clear from this research is how individual differences arise in the effects of the hormone withdrawal after menopause on brain functioning in middle aged women. It is possible that the estrogen control of the transcription of the PEMT gene may influence the availability of choline.
The investigators recently completed a study of one oral dose of 1650 mg choline versus placebo in 20 healthy postmenopausal women aged 50-65 years. Choline or placebo was administered three hours before an MRI session where subjects underwent an MRS scan as well as functional MRI scans. The MRS scans did not show differences in choline levels in the brain between the choline and placebo study days. However, the functional MRI (fMRI) results showed that choline modulated activation patterns during working memory task as well as influenced functional connectivity between memory relevant regions in the brain. The pattern of activation showed that during the choline challenge compared to placebo, there was decreased frontal activation and increased posterior activation during working memory. The functional connectivity analysis showed decreased connectivity during choline compared to placebo. This pattern of activation is similar to what has been shown with estradiol administration in healthy postmenopausal women. Recent choline data and prior estrogen data resulted in brain activation patterns similar to those of younger adults when compared to older adults. These results were interpreted to indicate that choline in a similar way to estradiol resulted in more efficient patterns of brain activation in healthy postmenopausal women.
This study will use a randomized placebo-controlled trial to examine smaller doses of choline and to detect a signal in the brain using fMRI. This study will examine if even smaller doses of choline can show these similar brain activation and connectivity patterns to the 1650 mg dose. This is a dose ranging study of 550 mg and 1100 mg oral choline compared to placebo.
