One-session Treatment for Spider Fears

Recent conceptualizations of the mechanisms by which exposure therapy (EXP; i.e., confronting one's fear in a systematic and therapeutic way) works in the treatment of phobias focus on the importance of extinction learning). This "inhibitory learning model" proposes that EXP helps the phobic individual learn that phobic stimuli are not dangerous; yet older danger-related learning is not "erased", and so must be inhibited by the new "safety learning." Research indicates that incorporating surprise into EXP (e.g., the patient is surprised that the spider didn't bite) maximizes this type of inhibitory learning and would correspond to better outcomes for phobias then when there is no surprise at the outcome of EXP. Traditionally, EXP is used with the addition of cognitive restructuring (CR), which involves discussing and disputing exaggerated beliefs that underlie one's fears (e.g., "spiders are very dangerous"). CR encourages phobic individuals to re-evaluate their expectations of danger when encountering phobic stimuli, and therefore might rob the individual of the opportunity to be surprised when actually facing their fear. Despite the theoretical plausibility of the importance of surprise during EXP, this question has yet to be investigated empirically. The aim of the present study is to test the hypothesis that incorporating surprise into EXP (by postponing CR until after EXP) will enhance immediate and long-term outcome of EXP for spider phobia.